Employer Guide to Employment Law | Gilson Gray

Employment Law for Employers: Building Fair, Robust and Legally Sound Workplace Practices

BlogEmployment LawInsights
Employment Law for Employers: Building Fair, Robust and Legally Sound Workplace Practices
Steven Eckett

Employment Law for Employers: A Practical Guide

Employment law is rarely static, and as employers we feel that reality every day. From managing conduct and performance issues and restructuring teams to dealing with complex grievances and discrimination risks, our responsibilities go far beyond simply issuing contracts of employment and paying remuneration. When employment issues arise, they rarely stay “HR‑only” for long – they can quickly affect morale, productivity, brand reputation and, in the worst cases, lead to costly and time-consuming Employment Tribunal claims. That is why understanding employment law from the employer’s perspective is about much more than compliance; it is about understanding our legal obligations and in turn protecting our organisation and our people in a balanced, sustainable way.

At Gilson Gray, we work with employers of all shapes and sizes across Scotland and the wider UK, helping them build robust and fair processes and procedures that stand up to legal scrutiny while still being manageable in a real-life setting. We see, on a daily basis, how early, timely practical advice can prevent a difficult situation from turning into a formal dispute. Whether we are advising a growing business on its first staff handbook, guiding HR through a complex disciplinary issue or negotiating the terms of an executive exit, our focus is always on clear risk assessment whilst weighing up commercial, realistic solutions.

In this article, we look at employment law through the employer lens – the key risks to watch for, the processes that really matter, and how investing in the right approach at an early stage can save significant time, money and stress later. Rather than quoting legislation at you, we want to share how we apply the law in practice so that you can feel more confident when making decisions that affect your workforce.

Getting the basics right: contracts, policies and employment status issues

From an employer’s perspective, the foundations of good employment practice and procedure are often the most overlooked. Written contracts of employment, up‑to‑date policies and procedures and clarity around employment status are essential if we want to manage expectations and reduce disagreements and disputes. Clear contractual terms promote clarity and help avoid arguments about hours of work, remuneration and benefits, notice periods and post‑termination restrictions, while a well‑structured staff handbook gives managers and employees a consistent reference point for the day‑to‑day handling of matters, for example handling sickness absence, and internal performance and conduct issues.

Employment status still remains a high‑risk area for many employers, particularly where casual, freelance or gig‑style arrangements are involved. If we misclassify individuals as self‑employed or as “workers” when they are in reality employees, we expose ourselves to the risk of backdated holiday pay, pension payments, unpaid notice, redundancy rights and potential unfair dismissal claims.  There could also be tax ramifications if income tax and national insurance deductions have not been made to HMRC.  Regularly reviewing working arrangements against current guidance and case law is therefore crucial, especially in fast‑moving sectors. Public bodies such as ACAS provide valuable clear, accessible guidance and Codes of Practice on employment status and core rights, which we often recommend as a useful baseline for HR and managers who are not legally trained.

We also know from experience that templates found online are rarely enough on their own and can be out of date and incomplete and not tailored to the needs of the business. Our team routinely tailors contracts and policies so that they reflect our business reality and needs– for example, shift patterns, hybrid working expectations, confidentiality needs and intellectual property and GDPR concerns. Taking the time to get these documents and policies right and bringing them to the attention of our staff pays dividends when something goes wrong and we need to demonstrate that staff knew what was expected of them from the outset.

Managing conduct and performance fairly

Conduct and performance issues are a fact of working life, but how we approach them as employers can make the difference between a manageable situation and a dispute that spirals and escalates out of control. A fair disciplinary or capability process usually requires clear rules and consistent treatment, proper investigation, and an opportunity for the employee to respond and fully defend any allegations, with the statutory right to be accompanied by a work colleague or trade union representative.   Rushing to dismiss an employee without following a fair and structured process can significantly increase the risk of an unfair dismissal finding at the Employment Tribunal, especially for employees with the requisite qualifying length of service.

From our vantage point, many employers run into difficulty because line managers are unsure of the correct steps or mix conduct and performance concerns together without a clear framework. We frequently support employers by drafting or refining disciplinary and capability procedures, training managers on how to consistently apply them, and advising in real time on tricky cases – for example where allegations of misconduct overlap with possible mental health or disability issues where there could be a risk of discrimination. This joined‑up view is particularly important as the legal test for “reasonableness” in dismissals looks at both the reason for the decision and the procedure followed and whether it was followed reasonably.

The introduction of new legislation, for example the new Employment Rights Act 2025, continues to raise the bar on what Employment Tribunals expect from employers. Keeping up to date with ACAS Codes of Practice and guidance, and using those as a benchmark for internal procedures, is a practical way to minimise risk and legal exposure. When we work with employers, we aim to strike a balance: robust consistent processes that protect the organisation, without creating bureaucracy that makes it impossible for managers to deal with issues promptly and confidently.

Equality, discrimination and workplace culture

Equality and discrimination are now at the heart of employment risk management. Claims involving discrimination or harassment/victimisation can be particularly costly, time‑consuming and damaging to reputation, with compensation uncapped and media interest often significant. From an employer’s point of view, it is no longer enough to have an equality policy “on the shelf” and to pay lip service to it; we need to be able to show that we take active, reasonable steps to prevent discrimination and harassment/victimisation and that we respond effectively  and quickly when concerns are raised.

In practice, that means having clear, well‑communicated policies on equal opportunities, anti‑harassment and bullying, and ensuring these are reflected and aligned in training and day‑to‑day behaviour. Complaints should be taken seriously, investigated promptly and handled sensitively, with appropriate action implemented where allegations are upheld. Our team frequently assists employers in designing and implementing these frameworks, as well as supporting internal investigations when allegations arise. We understand firsthand how testing these situations can be, particularly when senior staff are involved or when allegations cut across long‑standing working relationships.

We have seen an increase in expectations on employers from Regulatory bodies, Courts/Tribunals and prospective employees around equality, diversity, inclusion and psychological safety at work. Drawing on our experience of acting for both employers and employees, we can offer an informed view of what “good ” looks like in practice, helping organisations assess where their culture and processes may be vulnerable and what steps they can take to update and strengthen them. Taking these issues seriously is not only a legal necessity; it plays a key role in attracting and retaining talent in a competitive market.

Restructuring, redundancy and organisational change

Restructuring is sometimes unavoidable – whether because of market conditions, technological change or strategic shifts. However, from an employer standpoint, the way we plan and execute redundancy exercises is critical to legal compliance and staff morale. A fair redundancy process demands a clear business rationale, meaningful consultation, transparent selection criteria and consideration of suitable alternative roles and consideration of possible redeployment opportunities to try and prevent the need for redundancies and to minimise any impact. Failure in any of these areas can expose us to individual unfair dismissal claims and, in larger exercises, collective consultation liabilities and protective awards.

We regularly guide employers through reorganisations ranging from a single role to multi‑site restructures. Our involvement typically begins at the planning stage: reviewing business proposals, testing the legal rationale for redundancy, and designing consultation timelines and documentation. When collective consultation obligations apply, we advise on the election of employee representatives, information requirements and tactical considerations around timing and communication. These early decisions often shape the overall risk profile of the project and its impact on the business.

Settlement agreements are another key tool for employers managing change or dispute resolution. Used correctly, they provide certainty and a quick clean break, with appropriate financial terms and agreed wording around confidentiality and references and other obligations. We assist organisations in drafting and negotiating these agreements, ensuring that they properly waive the intended claims within a proper legal framework, while remaining reasonable and enforceable. Being strategic about when and how to use settlement agreements can significantly reduce the time, resources and emotional energy spent on dealing with disputes.

Working with external guidance and support

No employer operates entirely in isolation. Public guidance from bodies such as ACAS and GOV.UK offers a helpful baseline on employment rights, procedures and best practice. For example, ACAS codes of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures are frequently considered by tribunals when assessing whether an employer has acted reasonably. Referring to these resources when designing or updating internal processes is a straightforward, practical way to keep policy aligned with wider expectations and to ensure consistency and reasonableness in their implementation.

At the same time, general guidance has its limits. Every organisation has its own structure, risk appetite and culture, and decisions often need to be taken quickly in the context of specific disputes and internal conflicts and needs. That is where having a relationship with a specialist employment law team becomes particularly valuable. We pride ourselves on offering employers tailored, timely commercial advice that recognises the pressures they are under – whether that is budget constraints, tight timescales, stakeholder expectations or reputational concerns.

Our wider firm structure, incorporating legal, property and financial services, means we can also support employers when employment issues intersect with other areas – for example, business acquisitions, shareholder disputes and/or director exits. This integrated approach helps ensure that employment law decisions do not inadvertently create problems elsewhere in the organisation and that change programmes are managed coherently from both a legal and a commercial point of view.

Building a proactive, confident approach to employment law

Ultimately, approaching employment law from the employer’s perspective is about moving from fire‑fighting to proactive management. When we know our contracts are robust, our policies are consistent and clear and our managers are supported, we can handle day‑to‑day issues with greater confidence. Investing in training and regular policy reviews, drawing on trusted public guidance, and seeking early legal input on higher‑risk situations all contribute to a more stable, predictable working environment.

Our experience shows that when employers treat employment law as part of strategic risk management rather than an afterthought, they see benefits far beyond reduced legal exposure. Grievances tend to be resolved earlier, and to the satisfaction of the complainant, Employment Tribunals become rarer, and staff are more likely to feel heard and fairly treated, even when outcomes are difficult. For us, the goal is straightforward: help employers make fair, defensible decisions that support the long‑term health of their organisation and which in turn builds the trust and confidence and expectations of their workforce.

 

Steven Eckett's portait
Steven Eckett
Partner, Head of Employment (England)

Steven is a Partner and Head of Employment for England. He has extensive experience in advising clients, both employers and employees, on a wide range of employment issues from the beginning of the employment relationship through to its termination and beyond.

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!