When Is a Free Drink Not Really Free? - Gilson Gray

When Is a Free Drink Not Really Free?

BlogInsightsLicensing
When Is a Free Drink Not Really Free?
Arlene Dunbar

A complimentary glass of fizz at an event, a glass of wine while having your hair done, or a “free” drink included with an entry ticket might seem straightforward. But when it comes to alcohol licensing in Scotland, “free” does not always mean free.

Under the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005, alcohol cannot generally be sold on premises unless the sale is authorised by a premises licence or an occasional licence. Selling alcohol without the appropriate authorisation is a criminal offence.

“But I’m Not Selling It, I’m Giving It Away”

Section 3 of the 2005 Act makes the position less straightforward than it appears. It states that certain supplies of alcohol are treated as a sale even when no separate charge is made. This includes alcohol supplied pursuant to a right acquired under a contract.

Examples include:

  • All-Inclusive Packages: In an “all-inclusive” hotel or resort package, the drinks may be described as “free”, but the customer has paid for a package that entitles them to receive them. The supply is therefore treated as a sale.
  • Vouchers and Tokens: The same applies where alcohol is provided in exchange for a voucher or token purchased elsewhere. No money changes hands when the drink is served, but it is still legally a sale.

The £25 Event Ticket vs. The £60 Haircut

To understand how this applies in practice, consider two common scenarios.

Scenario 1: The Event Ticket

Imagine an event advertised as:

“Tickets £25, including a complimentary glass of prosecco on arrival.”

No separate charge is made for the prosecco, and no money changes hands when it is served. However, because the £25 ticket gives the holder a contractual right to receive the drink, the supply is treated as a sale. Calling it “free”, “complimentary”, or “included” does not alter the legal reality.

For many one-off events, the issue can often be addressed through an occasional licence rather than a full premises licence. However, organisers should consider licensing requirements before tickets go on sale.

Scenario 2: The Hair Salon

Suppose a salon charges £60 for a haircut and offers customers a glass of wine. Payment for the haircut does not automatically mean the wine has been sold. The

key question is whether the customer has a contractual right to receive the alcohol as part of the service purchased.

Compare these two approaches:

  • Approach A: “Haircut and complimentary glass of prosecco – £60.” Here, the alcohol forms part of the paid package and is likely to be treated as a sale.
  • Approach B: The salon charges £60 solely for a haircut but chooses, at its discretion, to offer a customer a glass of wine as a gesture of hospitality. In those circumstances, there may be a stronger argument that the wine is being provided as a genuine act of hospitality rather than pursuant to a contractual right. However, much will depend on the facts and on how the arrangement operates in practice.

Businesses should be cautious. The substance of the arrangement matters more than the language used to describe it.

A business cannot necessarily avoid licensing requirements simply by removing references to alcohol from its advertising. If the provision of alcohol is, in reality, part of the customer experience that is routinely provided and factored into the overall price, a licensing board may look beyond the wording used and consider the substance of the arrangement.

Why This Matters for Non-Licensed Businesses

Section 1 of the 2005 Act prohibits the sale of alcohol on premises unless authorised by a licence. Anyone who sells alcohol, or knowingly allows alcohol to be sold, in breach of this provision commits an offence.

This issue is surprisingly easy to overlook for businesses that do not regard themselves as part of the licensed trade, such as:

  • Hair and beauty salons
  • Art galleries and boutique retailers
  • Event planners and experiential marketers
  • Independent accommodation providers

In many cases, the issue can be addressed through an occasional licence. Businesses hosting one-off events should consider whether an occasional licence is required before alcohol is offered to attendees.

The Takeaway: Look at the Whole Arrangement

The lesson is simple: in licensing law, the question is not whether the drink is described as “free”, but whether someone has paid for the right to receive it. If they have, the law may treat that drink as a sale, with all of the licensing consequences that follow.

A genuinely gratuitous gift, where the customer has no contractual entitlement to receive alcohol, may be treated differently. However, local licensing boards may scrutinise these arrangements carefully, and the line between hospitality and an unauthorised sale can be a fine one.

As with many areas of licensing law, each case turns on its own facts. Businesses should be cautious about assuming that describing alcohol as “complimentary” or “free” will remove the need for licensing authorisation.

Because breaches of the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 can carry significant legal and criminal consequences, businesses should seek specialist advice before offering alcohol as part of an event, promotion, or customer experience. It is also prudent to discuss any proposed arrangement with the relevant licensing authority at an early stage.

Before offering alcohol as part of a promotion, event, or customer experience, ask yourself one question: would the customer still receive exactly the same thing if they had not paid for the ticket, package, or service? If the answer is no, licensing requirements may require careful consideration.

After all, that “free” glass of fizz may not be quite as free as you think.

Arlene Dunbar
Team Lead, Licensing 
Phone:01224 011 691
Email:  [email protected]

The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only.  They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice.  Before acting on anything contained in this blog, please seek a solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

Arlene Dunbar's portait
Arlene Dunbar
Licensing Team Lead

Arlene is a Licensing Team Lead and Senior Accredited Paralegal within Gilson Gray’s Corporate Team, specialising in Licensing Law and is based in our Aberdeen Office.

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!