Premises Licence Objections and Licensing Board Hearings - Gilson Gray

Premises Licence Objections and Licensing Board Hearings

BlogInsightsLicensing
Premises Licence Objections and Licensing Board Hearings
Arlene Dunbar

Licensing Law Series | Part 5 of 6

Managing Objections and Hearings: Presenting the Strongest Possible Case

Welcome to Part 5 of our series, Getting Your Premises Licence Granted: A Practical Guide

In Part 4, we explored overprovision and how applicants can distinguish their premises from existing provision within a locality. This week, we turn to another aspect of the licensing process that can cause concern for applicants: objections, representations and Licensing Board hearings.

For many applicants, receiving notice of an objection can feel like a major setback. However, objections are a routine part of the licensing process and should not automatically be viewed as an indication that an application is likely to fail.

Many premises licence applications that attract objections are ultimately granted. The outcome often depends on how effectively applicants identify concerns, engage with objectors and present their case before the Licensing Board.

Understanding Objections and Representations

Under the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005, members of the public, community organisations and responsible authorities have an opportunity to comment on premises licence applications. Objections relating to the statutory grounds of refusal may be submitted, while representations may be made in support of an application or to suggest modifications.

Common sources of objections include:

  • Local residents.
  • Community councils.
  • Police Scotland.
  • Licensing Standards Officers.
  • Environmental Health Officers.
  • Other interested parties.

The existence of an objection is only the starting point. The Licensing Board must ultimately assess the relevance and weight of the concerns being advanced.

Why Objections Are Made

Most objections arise because objectors believe the application may have a negative impact on one or more of the licensing objectives. These concerns may relate to:

  • Potential increases in noise.
  • Crime and disorder.
  • Public safety issues.
  • Impact on children and young persons.
  • Public health concerns.
  • Existing levels of licensed provision.

In some cases, objections are based on misunderstandings about the nature of the proposal. In others, they may raise genuine concerns that require careful consideration.

The key for applicants is to understand not only what is being objected to, but why.

Don’t Ignore the Objection

One of the biggest mistakes applicants can make is assuming that objections can simply be dealt with at the hearing.

As soon as objections are received, applicants should carefully review them and consider:

  • What specific concern is being raised?
  • Is the concern linked to a licensing objective?
  • Is there evidence supporting the concern?
  • Can the issue be addressed through clarification or amendment?

Early analysis often reveals opportunities to resolve concerns before they escalate.

Consider Whether Amendments Are Appropriate

Not every objection requires an amendment to the application. However, there are occasions where reasonable modifications can significantly strengthen an applicant’s position.

Examples may include:

  • Reducing terminal hours.
  • Limiting outdoor drinking.
  • Introducing additional CCTV.
  • Enhancing staff training provisions.
  • Restricting certain activities.
  • Accepting additional licence conditions.

Licensing Boards often view flexibility as evidence that an applicant is focused on promoting the licensing objectives rather than simply obtaining the broadest possible licence.

The key is ensuring that any amendment remains commercially viable while addressing the concerns identified.

Preparing for a Licensing Board Hearing

If objections remain unresolved, the application may proceed to a Licensing Board hearing.

For some applicants, this will be an unfamiliar experience. However, thorough preparation can significantly reduce anxiety and improve the overall presentation of the case.

Applicants should start by reviewing:

  • The premises licence application.
  • The operating plan.
  • All objections and representations.
  • Correspondence from responsible authorities.
  • Relevant Licensing Board policies.
  • Supporting evidence and reports.

A hearing should never be the first time an applicant considers how they will respond to concerns.

Anticipate the Board’s Questions

Licensing Board members are seeking reassurance that the premises will operate responsibly and consistently with the licensing objectives. Applicants should therefore be prepared to answer questions such as:

  • Why are the proposed hours appropriate?
  • How will noise be controlled?
  • What age-verification measures will be in place?
  • How will staff be trained?
  • What steps will be taken to prevent crime and disorder?
  • Why is the licence required in this particular location?

Applicants who can provide clear, confident and evidence-based answers are more likely to inspire confidence.

The Value of Supporting Evidence

Evidence can often be the deciding factor in a contested application.

Depending on the nature of the concerns raised, useful supporting documentation may include:

  • Acoustic reports.
  • Noise management plans.
  • CCTV policies.
  • Staff training procedures.
  • Business plans.
  • Economic impact information.
  • Photographs and site plans.
  • Letters of support.

The more objective evidence available, the easier it becomes for a Licensing Board to assess the application on its merits.

When Expert Evidence May Help

Some applications involve complex issues that may benefit from professional input.

Applicants may wish to seek assistance from:

  • Licensing solicitors.
  • Acoustic consultants.
  • Architects.
  • Planning consultants.

Independent professional evidence can be particularly valuable where objections raise technical issues that fall outside the Licensing Board’s own expertise.

Professionalism Matters

Applicants should approach hearings in a professional and constructive manner. Licensing Boards are looking for reassurance that premises will be operated responsibly and that concerns raised during the process have been properly considered. A calm, evidence-based presentation is usually far more persuasive than an argumentative one.

A Hearing Is an Opportunity

It is easy to view a Licensing Board hearing as an obstacle. In practice, it is often an applicant’s best opportunity to explain the proposal, address concerns, and demonstrate why the application should be granted.

A well-prepared applicant can use the hearing to:

  • Correct misunderstandings.
  • Clarify operating procedures.
  • Highlight community benefits.
  • Demonstrate compliance measures.
  • Reinforce promotion of the licensing objectives.

Many successful applications are approved precisely because applicants use the hearing process effectively.

Key Takeaway

Objections do not automatically lead to refusal, and a Licensing Board hearing should not be viewed as something to fear.

Applicants who engage constructively, prepare thoroughly and focus on addressing concerns through evidence and practical solutions place themselves in the strongest possible position. In many cases, the hearing process becomes an opportunity to strengthen rather than weaken the application.

Ultimately, Licensing Boards are looking for reassurance that premises will be operated responsibly and, in a manner, consistent with the licensing objectives. Applicants who can provide that reassurance are often well placed to secure a positive outcome.

Coming Next Week

Over the course of this series, we have explored the principal reasons premises licence applications encounter difficulties and the practical steps that can be taken to address them.

In the final part of our series, we’ll bring everything together with ten practical tips to maximise your chances of securing a premises licence and avoiding refusal under the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005.

Arlene Dunbar
Team Lead, Licensing 
Phone:01224 011 691
Email:  [email protected]

The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only.  They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice.  Before acting on anything contained in this blog, please seek a solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

Arlene Dunbar's portait
Arlene Dunbar
Licensing Team Lead

Arlene is a Licensing Team Lead and Senior Accredited Paralegal within Gilson Gray’s Corporate Team, specialising in Licensing Law and is based in our Aberdeen Office.

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!