What is a Disclosure Letter? - Gilson Gray
What is a Disclosure Letter?
Louis Francis Gilson Gray

In a corporate transaction, the disclosure letter serves as an important instrument in disclosing potential risks to the buyer as well as allocating that risk between the buyer and seller in relation to the target company. It operates as a set of exceptions to the warranties provided in the primary agreement between the two parties (for example, a share purchase agreement). The purpose is to ensure that the buyer cannot later claim for breach of warranty concerning matters fairly disclosed prior to completion.

Structure

A disclosure letter typically comprises of the following:

General Disclosures

These are disclosures that the buyer is deemed to know or ought to have discovered through standard due diligence. This may include matters that are on the public record such as Companies House or the Land Register of Scotland (or equivalent). Previously disclosed accounts and contents of the “data room” already provided during due diligence would typically be encompassed as a “general disclosure”.

In addition, typical “general disclosures” (amongst others) may also include the target’s company’s articles of association, meeting minutes and information contained in the statutory registers.

Specific Disclosures

These are disclosures that are made against individual warranties provided in the primary agreement between the parties. These “specific disclosures” provide detailed factual exceptions to those warranties. Each specific disclosure is considered to qualify or carve out an exception against a particular warranty which in turn limits the buyer’s ability to bring a warranty claim against that specific warranty.

For example, the seller could warrant that the target company is not engaged in a litigation dispute. However, if the target company is in an employment dispute with an employee, the starting point would be that the seller has breached that warranty. To avoid a warranty claim, the seller, should disclose this fact to the buyer in advance and include the details in the disclosure letter. It should be noted, that it would ordinarily be the case that any potential liability that is identified in this way would be covered by a specific indemnity in the share purchase agreement, often with an agreed limitation of liability based on the potential financial impact on the target company.

Disclosure Bundle

This is a bundle of documents attached to the disclosure letter. It will consist of a set supporting documents that substantiate or evidence the disclosures made in the disclosure letter, particularly in regards to the “specific disclosures”.

The bundle serves to demonstrate “fair disclosure”, clarify or evidence any matters disclosed and protect the seller from potential post completion warranty claims. The bundle can include (but not limited to) documents such as: board minutes, shareholder resolutions, key contracts, HR records and any litigation correspondence or writs.

Fair Disclosure

“Fair disclosure”, defines the standard by which a seller’s disclosure will be deemed sufficient to qualify or exclude liability for a breach of warranty. In order to meet the standard of “fairly disclosed”, the parties should consider the following:

 

  • A disclosure must go beyond vague and high-level references. It should provide sufficient factual detail in order for the buyer to understand the significance of the disclosure. For example it is simply not enough to say the seller is in a “litigation dispute”. There needs to be more information disclosed such as the parties and the potential cost of the dispute;
  • A disclosure that buries important information in a large data room or disclosure bundle without any specific reference to it in the letter could be deemed unfair even if the information was technically accessible;
  • Disclosure is assessed objectively and does not typically include subjective knowledge tests unless the primary agreement between the parties incorporates such tests; and
  • The disclosure letter should clearly cross reference disclosures to specific warranties and to the relevant document in the disclosure bundle with proper indexing throughout.
Conclusion

The disclosure letter can be an essential transactional tool that balances the allocation of risk between buyer and seller in corporate transactions. Conducting due diligence on its own does not negate the importance of formal disclosures as only matters disclosed in the disclosure letter will typically qualify the warranties. An effective disclosure letter requires expert drafting and integration with the primary agreement to ensure enforceability and clarity.

View our full corporate service offering here.

Louis Francis
trainee Solicitor, corporate
Phone:
Email:  [email protected]

 

Calum Crighton
Partner, Head of Energy
Phone:01224 011687
Email:  [email protected]

The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only.  They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice.  Before acting on any information contained in this blog, please seek solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

Louis Francis's portait
Louis Francis
Solicitor

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!