Warranties and Indemnities in a Share Sale - Gilson Gray

Warranties and Indemnities in a Share Sale

BlogCorporateEnergyIn The NewsInsightsOil & Gas
Warranties and Indemnities in a Share Sale
Louis Francis Gilson Gray

Given the nature of the share acquisition, the legal and commercial framework underpinning the transaction, often heavily relies on warranties and indemnities. These mechanisms serve to allocate risk and provide recourse in the event of undisclosed liabilities or inaccuracies in the information provided by the seller of the shares.

Warranties

Warranties are contractual statements of fact relating to the shares and/or the target company, typically given by the seller at the date of signing of the share purchase agreement and at the date of completion of the share purchase agreement, should signing and completion not be simultaneous. The volume and type of warranties that are given by both parties, typically depend on the value of the deal, the amount of legal due diligence undertaken and the risk appetite of the buyer. However, they cover a broad range of matters, including:

  • Ownership of shares (title and capacity);
  • Financial statements and accounts;
  • Material contracts;
  • Employees, pensions and tax;
  • Litigation and disputes;
  • Intellectual property; and
  • Environmental matters.

The function of warranties serves to provide two main purposes;

  1. They encourage full disclosure by the seller, ensuring the buyer is informed of the company’s affairs; and
  2. They provide a contractual basis for the buyer to claim damages.

If a buyer believes that a breach of warranty has taken place, the buyer must be able to demonstrate that the following requirements have been met;

  • The specific warranty was breached;
  • The breach caused loss and has impacted the value of the shares purchased (e.g. the share value has decreased); and
  • The loss is not expressly excluded by the SPA or has been deemed disclosed in the disclosure letter.

Without those requirements being met, it is unlikely that a claim for a breach of warranty will be successful.

Indemnities

Indemnities differ from warranties in that they are contractual obligations to reimburse the buyer for specific losses or liabilities, often these are known risks identified during due diligence. Common indemnity areas include:

  • Tax liabilities pre-dating completion;
  • Litigation protection;
  • Environmental claims; and
  • Employment claims.

Unlike warranties, the buyer need only demonstrate that the indemnified event occurred and caused the specific loss that was indemnified. The buyer should be able to recover that loss pound for pound, provided that the indemnity is framed as a debt claim.

That being said, in order to ensure that a claim on an indemnity provision is successful, it is important to distinctly state what event or circumstance will trigger the seller’s liability in regards to the indemnity and the value of any liability or how that value is calculated.

Risk Allocation and Drafting Considerations

When drafting the share purchase agreement, both the buyer and the seller will need to carefully consider the risk allocation and the scope of the warranties / indemnities being provided. Not limited to the below, the parties should consider the following:

  • Scope of warranties

Sellers may resist broad or forward-looking warranties whereas buyers will seek objective, factual statements. Within this, the seller may include limitations that only require them to warrant matters within their actual knowledge whereas a buyer may seek to warrant matters that may not fall within the knowledge of the seller.

  • Disclosure

A disclosure letter is essential in limiting warranty liability, this is because if a matter has been properly disclosed in the agreed disclosure letter, it cannot usually form the basis of a future claim. The disclosure letter will be negotiated between the parties and enables the seller to limit its liability in relation to any matters that it expressly sets out in the disclosure letter.

  • Caps and thresholds

Sellers commonly negotiate liability caps (e.g. a limitation of overall liability up to the purchase price) and “de Minimis” or “basket” thresholds before liability arises. What this means is that for the buyer to raise a claim for a breach of warranty, (i) the specific breach must exceed an agreed value (de Minimis) and (ii) the total claim for all breaches of warranty (at any given time) must exceed an agreed value (basket). Typically a seller will want a higher de Minimis or basket threshold compared to a buyer who will seek to obtain a lower threshold.

  • Time limits

General warranty claims often have a limitation period of 12–24 months, with tax indemnities and title warranties surviving for up to 6–7 years. However, these are subject to negotiation and the limitation period can often be increased or decreased.

  • Buyers Duty

Buyers are under an obligation to take reasonable steps to avoid incurring loss, or to mitigate loss, that occurs from a breach of warranty. If buyers are not in compliance with this obligation, it may affect the value of the sum that can be claimed / recovered from the seller.

Final Thoughts

It is without doubt that warranties and indemnities are fundamental to share sales in respect of both the buyer and the seller. The parties’ negotiating power and the findings of due diligence, all shape the ultimate allocation of liability. Precision in drafting and an understanding of the commercial context are essential to ensuring effective risk management and advice.

View our full corporate service offering here.

Louis Francis
trainee Solicitor, corporate
Phone:
Email:  [email protected]

 

Calum Crighton
Partner, Head of Energy
Phone:01224 011687
Email:  [email protected]

The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only.  They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice.  Before acting on any information contained in this blog, please seek solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

Louis Francis's portait
Louis Francis
Solicitor

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!