The new unfair dismissal regime and its impact on football clubs. Is it an open goal? - Gilson Gray

The new unfair dismissal regime and its impact on football clubs. Is it an open goal?

BlogCorporateEmployment LawInsightsSport
The new unfair dismissal regime and its impact on football clubs. Is it an open goal?
Steven Eckett

The Employment Rights Act 2025 received Royal Assent just before Christmas 2025, and part of the Government’s employment law reforms was to make ordinary unfair dismissal a day one right.

This did not transpire because of opposition during the bill’s passage through Parliament and the House of Lords, and so the Government agreed to a compromise on a reduction to the qualifying period of continuous service for ordinary unfair dismissal claims from two years to just six months.

At the same time, and quite unexpectedly, the Government also removed the statutory cap for compensatory awards (increasing to £123,543 on 6 April 2026). These reforms to the law on ordinary unfair dismissal are scheduled to take effect from 1 January 2027.

Implications for Football Clubs

The implications for professional football clubs and their managers are significant and stark, given the high levels of remuneration that are often involved.

Many managers and professional footballers have had limited protection against ordinary unfair dismissal because many do not reach the two-year anniversary required to pursue a claim. In addition, many earn significantly more than the current statutory cap on unfair dismissal compensation, making such a remedy ineffectual.

The removal of the statutory cap on unfair dismissal claims, combined with a shorter qualifying period of six months (and an increase in the limitation period from three months to six months), will mean that managers and footballers who are wronged can be awarded significant sums for ordinary unfair dismissal.

It is also going to be easier for such managers and players to pursue claims for constructive dismissal where they resign in response to any fundamental breach of contract. This can be in circumstances where the club undermines a manager’s authority or creates a difficult working environment. The removal of the statutory cap means that for these types of employees, a claim of unfair or constructive dismissal will be easier and much more appealing.

Greater Leverage

These changes to the UK’s unfair dismissal landscape are also likely to mean that such managers and players will have a greater degree of leverage when it comes to settlement negotiations, and in circumstances where both parties seek a clean break on mutually agreed terms.

The removal of the statutory cap means that financial losses based on a manager or player’s actual salary and benefits, or the cutting short of a fixed-term contract, will mean that they are likely to have a higher degree of leverage and bargaining power.

Even allowing a fixed-term contract to expire without renewing it could result in claims for ordinary unfair dismissal. We are, therefore, likely to see such negotiations becoming more complex, protracted and resulting in larger settlement sums.

Fair Performance Management

These changes to the UK’s unfair dismissal regime mean that clubs are going to have to become much more effective in managing a player’s performance by implementing fair performance management and dismissal processes, in order to minimise the risk of legal exposure that is going to become more inevitable.

Managers and players will still be under a duty to mitigate their financial losses, however, given the high remuneration levels some players enjoy, even a short period of unemployment could result in significant financial exposure to clubs who get it wrong.

It isn’t only high-earning managers and players who will have increased unfair dismissal rights to pursue, but also academy players lower down the ranking who earn significantly less.

Although they may earn significantly less than premier players, many are on fixed-term contracts that are longer than six months. In the event of their employment being terminated, they may struggle to find alternative employment, especially if they lose their jobs out of season, which is also likely to increase their financial losses and the value of any potential unfair dismissal claim.

Preparation

These changes to the UK’s unfair dismissal laws are significant, and their impact on football clubs cannot be underestimated.

It will be essential that clubs have in place carefully tailored employment contracts in place. This includes having a probationary period that is less than six months (which will be the new qualifying period for unfair dismissal) and where clubs will need to proactively assess managers and players’ performance. In addition, clubs will need to adopt clear, concise and consistent performance management procedures with clear records of any measures that are implemented as evidence. In addition, conduct and dismissal procedures will also need to be fair.

It is, therefore, recommended that clubs review and update their current employment contracts, policies and procedures in advance of the implementation of these changes. As ever, we recommend that timely legal advice be sought.

This article is part of a series being produced by Gilson Gray on the implementation of the Employment Rights Act 2025.

If you wish to find out more, contact a member of our team here.

Steven Eckett
Partner, Head of Employment (England)
Phone:020 4572 2566
Email:  [email protected]

The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only.  They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice.  Before acting on any information contained in this blog, please seek solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

Steven Eckett's portait
Steven Eckett
Partner, Head of Employment (England)

Steven is a Partner and Head of Employment for England. He has extensive experience in advising clients, both employers and employees, on a wide range of employment issues from the beginning of the employment relationship through to its termination and beyond.

Newsletter 
Sign up to our News & Insights!