
November 3, 2026
It’s anyone’s guess when there might be a decision in the Premier League v Man City FFP. This case, still ongoing as of mid-2025, centres on allegations that Manchester City breached over 100 Premier League rules relating to financial disclosures, sponsorship income, and cooperation with league investigations, offences said to have occurred between 2009 and 2018. While the club strongly denies any wrongdoing, the sheer volume and gravity of the charges have placed the integrity of the league’s financial regulatory framework under intense public scrutiny.
Financial Fair Play (FFP), in its various domestic and European guises, was originally introduced to encourage long-term financial sustainability in football. UEFA’s rules, introduced in 2011, focused on ensuring that clubs didn’t spend more than they earned, creating a break-even requirement designed to limit excessive losses and curb risky financial behaviour.
A secondary aim was to improve competitive balance across leagues and competitions by limiting the extent to which wealthy owners could ‘buy’ dominance through disproportionate investment. However, as academics like Plumley and Wilson (2023) have pointed out, the actual impact of these regulations on competition has been uneven at best. Dominance by clubs – like Bayern Munich, PSG, and yes, Manchester City – has continued largely unchecked, raising valid questions about whether FFP serves more to entrench elite control than to level the playing field.
This is not Manchester City’s first major regulatory battle. In 2020, the club successfully overturned a two-year Champions League ban imposed by UEFA, with the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) ruling that many of the alleged breaches were either not proven or time-barred. That decision dealt a significant blow to the credibility of UEFA’s enforcement mechanisms and, arguably, to the principle of financial control in elite football.
What makes the current Premier League case more complex is the divergence between UEFA’s FFP framework and the financial rules applied domestically in England. Unlike UEFA, which caps losses at €30m over three years, the Premier League allows up to £105m of permitted losses across the same period. The EFL, by contrast, operates with a £39m cap. These inconsistencies mean clubs moving between domestic and European competitions can face a shifting set of financial obligations, a structural flaw that undermines regulatory consistency and creates legal uncertainty.
The Premier League charges fall into five categories, each pointing to alleged violations of financial disclosure and integrity rules. The League must prove these breaches “to the comfortable satisfaction” of an independent disciplinary panel, a higher standard than mere balance of probabilities, but short of the criminal threshold.
What sets this process apart from ordinary legal disputes is that it sits within the specialised realm of sporting regulation, which is not bound by precedent in the same way as national courts. While CAS jurisprudence is not binding on the Premier League’s independent commission, it often serves as persuasive authority, particularly where questions of fact, evidence, and procedural fairness are concerned.
The panel’s decision will almost certainly consider whether any breach, if proven, warrants sanctions, and if so, how severe those should be. This will invoke the principle of proportionality: the idea that punishments must be balanced, fair, and appropriate in the context of the case. In short, the panel must weigh the facts, the seriousness of any misconduct, and the broader implications for the league’s credibility and competitive integrity.
Possible sanctions range from financial penalties and transfer bans to points deductions or, in the most severe scenario, expulsion from the league. If the commission does rule against Manchester City, arguments around proportionality will become central to any mitigation effort by the club.
That debate would also test the independence and fairness of English football’s judicial processes. There are those sitting in the “they must be punished because they are rich” camp that want Man City hung, drawn and quartered, as it were. Nevertheless, it is vital that decisions in this case are grounded in evidence and sound legal reasoning, not in political pressure or public narratives about wealth and dominance. Rhetoric such as has no place in principled adjudication.
This case is not just about one club, it is about the integrity of football’s regulatory frameworks in a time of intense financial and geopolitical change. Whether the issue is FFP, the threat of a revived European Super League, or state-backed investment in club football, the sport is at a crossroads.
The Premier League’s ability to enforce its own rules is now being put to the test in a way that could shape the next decade of governance and competition. Manchester City’s legal battle is not simply a story of alleged rule-breaking; it’s part of a much broader debate about how modern football balances financial power, legal fairness, and the ideals of sporting integrity.
Regardless of the outcome, the need for reform is evident. Football’s regulatory structures must be transparent, coherent, and fit for purpose, capable of withstanding legal challenge while upholding competitive fairness. The autonomy of sport depends on it.
| David Winnie Partner, Head of Sports and Immigration | ||||
|
The information and opinions contained in this blog are for information only. They are not intended to constitute advice and should not be relied upon or considered as a replacement for advice. Before acting on any information contained in this blog, please seek solicitor’s advice from Gilson Gray.

David is a Partner and Head of Sports, acting for individuals and organisations across the full spectrum of both contentious and non-contentious matters in the sports and commercial sector, as well as a experience in immigration law matters.